by Niels Bohr (2021)   Redaktion: Niels Bohr Arkivet (2022)  
previous next

1909, 28 April.

Letter? from Harald Bohr to Niels Bohr

A Copenhagen, Niels Bohr Archive, Harald Bohr Correspondence, HBC-BOHR-090428f. Letter, handwritten by Harald Bohr. On the envelope: Hr. stud. mag N. Bohr, Vissenbjerg Præstegaard, pr. Bred, Fyen, Dänemark

Dear Niels!

A thousand thanks for your card; I have still not begun Stages, as I am in the middle of (I am ashamed to say just begun) Goethe’s Dichtung und Wahrheit, which I want to finish before reading Kierkegaard; I am looking forward, in the fullness of time, to exchanging commentary about it with you. My lectures begin the day after tomorrow. Yesterday was an interesting day; which I dedicated to the transfinite Cantor numbers; Poincaré gave a lecture at 10 o’clock and afterwards, at 6 o’clock there was a long, interesting discussion at the Math. Gesell.., Hilbert's comments were particularly interesting. – I am working until now in a rather diffuse fashion, with small matters such as examples of Dirichlet series, with no singularity on the |convergence line itself but rather in “beliebiger Nahe” and the like, I have exchanged a series of letters with Landau, I, as he has requested of me, have formed all such examples; at any rate it is a useful exercise in writing German one achieves by this. Furthermore, I have also proven a little theorem that can be used a lot in anal. number theory: when \(|n\cdot a_n|\:\)   < Const. and \(\lim \frac{S_1 + \cdots + S_n}{n}\) exists , the series \(\sum a_n\) is always convergent. The proof is easy to use but very curious. – I am now beginning to take charge of my own things and am looking forward to publishing them. They have by now grown to quite a considerable amount. Here, I’d like to give one example of something I think I have told you before. The integral \(\int_0^\infty e^{it}t^{x-1}dt\) is, as you know, a “Dirichlet integral” (obvious when \(x-1\) is set equal to \(-y\); since the Diri. Int. have the form \(\int_0^\infty \frac{f(t)}{t^y}dt\); for these integrals I have proved that when they are summable of a given order at a point, |then they are always summable of the given order in the half-plane to the right thereof (in analogy with the theorem of the node). Here I will simply show how easily one can show summabili. of the mentioned integral \(\int_0^\infty e^{it} t^{x-1} dt\) in the whole half-plane to the left (since we have \(t^x\) “in the numerator” and not “in the denominator”)
Let \(x=n+1\) Then we have
$$s(x) = \int^x_0e^{it} \, {t^n dt} = \frac{1}{i}e^{ix} \cdot x^{n} +\cdots + (i)^{n + 1} \cdot n!$$
(this is what a simple partial integration yields)
$$s(x) \quad\text{is then equal to}\quad \sum_{r=0}^n k_r \cdot e^{ix} \cdot x^r + (i)^{n + 1} \cdot n!$$
since we now must integrate \(s(x)\) etc. ... \(n+1\) times and thereafter divide through by \(x^{n+1}\) (with \(n\) unkown) and take the limit (\(x=\infty\)) we see immediately that by this operation the first term must be \(0\), (namely since we can never get a power higher than \(x^n\) (either mult. by \(e^{ix}\) or by a const.) Since the other term is already constant (indep. of \(x\)) we get the value of summation equal to \(i^{n+1}\cdot n!\:\) Now following Niels Nielsen the gammafunction |
$$\int^{\infty}_{0} e^{it} \cdot t^{x-1} dt = \Gamma(x) \cdot e^{\frac{\pi xi}{2}} \quad \text{thus} $$
$$\int^{\infty}_0 \, e^{it} \, t^n \, dt = \Gamma (n + 1) \cdot e^{\frac{\pi i}{2} \cdot (n + 1)} = n! \, (i)^{n + 1}$$
So that all fits reasonably well. – I am furthermore engaging with the summability for series with completely arbitrary \(x_0 \; x_1 \cdots x_n \cdots\); they involve quite some puzzles and I think, in the Doctoral thesis, I will do the special series \(\sum \frac{a_{n}}{n^x}\) and the Integrals completely, and then settle for summability of 1storder for arbitrary series (where I can then let the series of indices be completely arbitrary). Now I will not bother you any more, as I have not yet anything to tell which will be surprising for you. The other day I was at Prof Verworn with a very mixed company (1 German Pr. V. one from England mrs. V., one Russian, one Japanese, one Hungarian and myself). It was cozy and nice. Now goodbye for today and have a very very nice time and many greetings to the Møllgaard family

Your faithful brother
Harald.

P.S. The anemones are still doing well and decorating my desk.

1r| P.S. I say with “great expectations” much fun, or rather much mischief when we are together again in Copenhagen. Hurra!

|